Global Warming With the Lid Off

The emails that reveal an effort to hide the truth about climate science.

NOVEMBER 24, 2009

The two MMs have been after the CRU station data for years. If they ever hear there is a Freedom of Information Act now in the U.K., I think I'll delete the file rather than send to anyone. . . . We also have a data protection act, which I will hide behind."

So apparently wrote Phil Jones, director of the University of East Anglia's Climate Research Unit (CRU) and one of the world's leading climate scientists, in a 2005 email to "Mike." Judging by the email thread, this refers to Michael Mann, director of the Pennsylvania State University's Earth System Science Center. We found this nugget among the more than 3,000 emails and documents released last week after CRU's servers were hacked and messages among some of the world's most influential climatologists were published on the Internet.

The "two MMs" are almost certainly Stephen McIntyre and Ross McKitrick, two Canadians who have devoted years to seeking the raw data and codes used in climate graphs and models, then fact-checking the published conclusions—a painstaking task that strikes us as a public and scientific service. Mr. Jones did not return requests for comment and the university said it could not confirm that all the emails were authentic, though it acknowledged its servers were hacked.

Yet even a partial review of the emails is highly illuminating. In them, scientists appear to urge each other to present a "unified" view on the theory of man-made climate change while discussing the importance of the "common cause"; to advise each other on how to smooth over data so as not to compromise the favored hypothesis; to discuss ways to keep opposing views out of leading journals; and to give tips on how to "hide the decline" of temperature in certain inconvenient data.

Some of those mentioned in the emails have responded to our requests for comment by saying they must first chat with their lawyers. Others have offered legal threats and personal invective. Still others have said nothing at all. Those who have responded have insisted that the emails reveal nothing more than trivial data discrepancies and procedural debates.

Yet all of these nonresponses manage to underscore what may be the most revealing truth: That these scientists feel the public doesn't have a right to know the basis for their climate-change predictions, even as their governments prepare staggeringly expensive legislation in response to them.

Consider the following note that appears to have been sent by Mr. Jones to Mr. Mann in May 2008: "Mike, Can you delete any emails you may have had with Keith re AR4? Keith will do likewise. . . . Can you also email Gene and get him to do the same?" AR4 is shorthand for the U.N.'s Intergovernmental Panel of Climate Change's (IPCC) Fourth Assessment Report, presented in 2007 as the consensus view on how bad man-made climate change has supposedly become.

In another email that seems to have been sent in September 2007 to Eugene Wahl of the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration's Paleoclimatology Program and to Caspar Ammann of the National Center for Atmospheric Research's Climate and Global Dynamics Division, Mr. Jones writes: "[T]ry and change the Received date! Don't give those skeptics something to amuse themselves with."

When deleting, doctoring or withholding information didn't work, Mr. Jones suggested an alternative in an August 2008 email to Gavin Schmidt of NASA's Goddard Institute for Space Studies, copied to Mr. Mann. "The FOI [Freedom of Information] line we're all using is this," he wrote. "IPCC is exempt from any countries FOI—the skeptics have been told this. Even though we . . . possibly hold relevant info the IPCC is not part of our remit (mission statement, aims etc) therefore we don't have an obligation to pass it on."

It also seems Mr. Mann and his friends weren't averse to blacklisting scientists who disputed some of their contentions, or journals that published their work. "I think we have to stop considering 'Climate Research' as a legitimate peer-reviewed journal," goes one email, apparently written by Mr. Mann to several recipients in March 2003. "Perhaps we should encourage our colleagues in the climate research community to no longer submit to, or cite papers in, this journal."

Mr. Mann's main beef was that the journal had published several articles challenging aspects of the anthropogenic theory of global warming.

For the record, when we've asked Mr. Mann in the past about the charge that he and his colleagues suppress opposing views, he has said he "won't dignify that question with a response." Regarding our most recent queries about the hacked emails, he says he "did not manipulate any data in any conceivable way," but he otherwise refuses to answer specific questions. For the record, too, our purpose isn't to gainsay the probity of Mr. Mann's work, much less his right to remain silent.

However, we do now have hundreds of emails that give every appearance of testifying to concerted and coordinated efforts by leading climatologists to fit the data to their conclusions while attempting to silence and discredit their critics. In the department of inconvenient truths, this one surely deserves a closer look by the media, the U.S. Congress and other investigative bodies.


PayPal - The safer, easier way to pay online!

To see all events Click Here

Mark Reed to speak at"Day of Politics" at Pierce College
The Great Hall at Pierce College
Apr 29, 2014

11:30am – 12:30pm  
Apr 29, 2014

Mark Reed to participate in Congressional Debate at LA Valley College.
L.A. Valley College
5800 Fulton Avenue
Valley Glen, 91401 -
Behavior Science Bldg., Room 100

May 8, 2014  
May 8, 2014

Mark Reed to Speak at the Woodland Hills Federated Republican Women's meeting
Woodland Hills Country Club

21150 Dumetz Rd
Woodland Hills, CA
(818) 347-1511

May 8, 2014
11:00 AM to 1:00 PM  
May 8, 2014

Mark Reed to speak at the Santa Monica Women's Federated
Riviera Country Club,
1250 Capri Drive
Pacific Palisades, CA 90272

(310) 454-6591

No host lunch or $25.00.  
May 14, 2014

Mark to appear on radio with Cameron Datzker.
I-Heart Radio
4730 Avenue, Suite 401
Sherman Oaks 91423
May 23, 2014
8:15pm – 9:15pm   
May 23, 2014

Mark Reed at Fourth Annual Valley Mega Mixer
Anheuser Busch
15800 Roscoe Blvd.
Van Nuys, CA 91406

Thu May 29, 2014
5pm – 8pm

$30 charge for non-members, either in advance or at the door. Self-parking available. Sponsored by Valley Chambers of Commerce.   
May 29, 2014

National Debt Clock

A million seconds pass in 12 days.
A billion seconds pass in 31 years.
A trillion seconds pass in 31,688 years!


Phone: (818) 353-8777

Sponsor an Event or Fundraiser for Mark Reed:

Address: P.O. Box 4181
Sunland California 91040

PayPal - The safer, easier way to pay online!

Donate By Mail

If you prefer to mail in a check, please use the link below to download a donation form. Make checks payable to Mark Reed for Congress, memoed "Primary Contribution" and mail it back to:

Mark Reed for Congress
P.O. Box 4181
Sunland CA 91040

Note: Federal Election Law requires contributors to provide the following information; Name, address, occupation, employer, phone number (day & evening) and Email address.

Download Donation Form

FEC#: H0CA27101
Go to the FEC Site

Campaign Committee#: C00462317